G. Sauter et K. Leonard, DESIGN METHODS FOR RESIDENTIAL WASTE-WATER TREATMENT, Journal of the american water resources association, 33(1), 1997, pp. 155-162
Constructed wetlands have recently gained popularity as an alternative
method for wastewater treatment. This paper compares two design metho
dologies currently used for constructed wetlands; Tennessee Valley Aut
hority (TVA) and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) methods. A
discussion of parameters for both methods is given and a wetland treat
ment system is designed for an individual residence with typical BOD5
loads and flow rates. Calculation results revealed significant discrep
ancies in the required constructed wetlands volume, and thus detention
time, stemming from inherent differences in the design methodologies.
The EPA method relies heavily on plug flow kinetics, and is therefore
sensitive to changes in the reaction rate constant and media porosity
. Conversely, TVA determines the surface area by sizing in accordance
with a recommended hydraulic loading criterion and is affected only by
the hydraulic flow rates. This study concluded that a constructed wet
land is a viable option under design considerations that are not favor
able for traditional on-site wastewater treatment methods. However, it
is recommended that conservative values for flow and loading rates be
assumed to assure complete treatment for either of the design methods
.