Le. Thomas et al., Melt generation beneath ocean islands: A U-Th-Ra isotope study from Lanzarote in the Canary Islands, GEOCH COS A, 63(23-24), 1999, pp. 4081-4099
New major and trace element data, and Sr, Nd, Ph, U, Th and Ra isotopes are
presented for prehistoric and historic lavas from Lanzarote in the Canary
Islands. These rocks are amongst the most primitive found on intraplate oce
an islands ranging in composition from basanite to alkali basalt, with MgO
contents >9.3% and Mg numbers >67. The youngest are from two of the three 1
824 vents, the largest group of samples is from the best known eruption epi
sode, the 1730-36 Timanfaya eruptions, a smaller group of samples are from
the northeast Corona region (similar to 50 ky) and the oldest samples are f
rom the Famara complex and basement massif. The rocks have some of the char
acteristics of HIMU GIB, including high Ce/Pb, Nb/Ce and low Nb/U and restr
icted Sr-87/Sr-86 (0.70209-0.70332). There is significant Th-230/U-238 dise
quilibrium (Th-230 excesses range from 6-76%) with some of the intermediate
silica composition Corona samples showing the greatest disequilibrium. The
historic samples exhibit Ra-226 excess. The major and trace element data h
ave undergone fractionation corrections to Mg numbers of 70, requiring <5%
olivine fractionation, and these inferred primary compositions ale used to
evaluate a number of melt generation and mixing models.
The fractionation-corrected compositions for the 1824 and the 1730-36 have
been modelled as 1-4% melts of a source similar to primitive mantle. Howeve
r, Yb is incompatible, and so the amounts of residual garnet were < similar
to 5%, suggesting that there was no significant contribution from garnet p
yroxenite source rocks. Rather the REE and the FeO contents are both consis
tent with melting in the garnet-spinel transition, at depths of 60-70 km. (
Th-230/U-238) increases slightly with increasing La/Yb, in:the younger rock
s, and they require Some form of dynamic melting model. In the preferred mo
del the upwelling rate is kept constant, and the differences in the degrees
of melting are attributed to different lengths of the melt column, with th
e smaller degree melts being extracted from greater depths. Strikingly, (Ra
-226/Th-230) increases with increasing degrees of melting, and so it reflec
ts the time since extraction from the-melt column rather than variations in
the melting processes. Intra-suite minor and trace element variations are
due to magma mixing, and not to progressive changes in the degrees of parti
al melting, and it is envisaged that such magma mixing occurred during the
dynamic melting processes. Dynamic melting at depths of 60-70 km suggests t
hat the regional uplift around the Canary Islands is at least in part due t
o thermal erosion of the underlying lithosphere.
Variations of average Ce/Yb, Tb/Yb, (Th-230/U-238), SiO2 and lithospheric a
ge for different OIB highlight how the smaller degree melts tend to be gene
rated at greater depths, and the mean pressure of melting increases with th
e thickness of the lithospheric lid. However, there is no general link betw
een (230Th/238U) and the:lithospheric age or thickness, and hence the integ
rated degrees of melting. High buoyancy fluxes result in higher degrees of
melting and low (Th-230/U-238) (Chabaux and Allegre, 1994), but for OIB gen
erated within low buoyancy plumes, (230Th/238U) and the degrees of melting
primarily depend on the depths of melt extraction. Differences in the avera
ge composition of low buoyancy OIB depend on the thickness of the overlying
lithosphere (Ellam, 1992; Haase, 1996), and the differences within an OIB
suite, such as between the 1730-36 and 1824 lavas on Lanzarote, depend on t
he depth of extraction from the melt column. Copyright (C) 1999 Elsevier Sc
ience Ltd.