A. Goguitchaichvili et al., Thermodetrital and crystallodetrital magnetization in an Icelandic hyaloclastite, J GEO R-SOL, 104(B12), 1999, pp. 29219-29238
An Icelandic hyaloclastite, mostly composed of millimetric fragments of bas
altic glass, that is fresh at the bottom of the unit but largely palagoniti
zed in the upper part, has been studied by petrologic, mineralogical, and m
agnetic means, with the aim of determining the nature and characteristics o
f the natural remanent magnetization (NRM). The NRM was generally found to
consist of two components: a thermodetrital remanent magnetization (thermo-
DRM) and a crystallodetrital remanent magnetization (crystallo-DRM). Thermo
-DRM and crystallo-DRM are defined here as the remanences acquired as a res
ult of the deposition of magnetic particles of detrital origin individually
carrying either a TRM (thermoremanent magnetization) or a CRM (crystalliza
tion remanent magnetization), respectively. Regardless of the chemistry and
size and of these particles, Thellier experiments carried out on samples c
arrying a thermo-DRM provide apparent paleointensities close to the expecte
d geomagnetic paleointensity, which suggests that in the present case the f
ractional alignment of individual magnetic moments is similar for DRM and T
RM. In the upper part of this outcrop, grain growth CRM was acquired by ind
ividual grains of magnetite which crystallized as a result of palagonitizat
ion of basaltic glass at low temperature (<100 degrees C). No systematic di
fference could be observed between the directions of characteristic remanen
ce in the layers richest in magmatic magnetic grains and the layer where se
condary magnetite is the main remanence carrier. In both cases, the overall
remanence exhibits a large inclination error (similar to 20 degrees), and
the samples have a marked anisotropy of magnetic susceptibility which is ty
pical of sedimentary fabrics. Thus, secondary magnetite probably formed pri
or to the deposition of particles, and the bulk remanence in the palagoniti
zed layers is a crystallo-DRM rather than a CRM. Throughout the entire stra
tigraphic thickness, Thellier paleointensity data are of good or excellent
quality regardless of the nature of the primary remanence. In agreement wit
h previous theoretical inferences and experimental results the layers carry
ing a crystallo-DRM provide a much lower (by a factor of 2) apparent paleoi
ntensity than the layers where the remanence is a thermo-DRM. This suggests
that palagonitized basaltic glasses should not be used for paleointensity
determinations. Our study shows that application of the Thellier thermal pa
leointensity method to sedimentary rocks can be a useful tool for distingui
shing crystalline versus thermal blocking of the magnetic moments of the in
dividual particles which, after deposition, carry a DRM. More generally, di
screpancies between relative paleointensities obtained from sediments can b
e expected if rocks with different. proportions of thermo-DRM, crystallo-DR
M, or CRM are compared.