A. Gilbert et O. Crankshaw, Comparing South African and Latin American experience: Migration and housing mobility in Soweto, URBAN STUD, 36(13), 1999, pp. 2375-2400
Given similar levels of economic development and inequality, it seems stran
ge that more effort has not been made by South Africans to learn from the e
arlier experience of urbanisation in countries such as Brazil, Chile and Co
lombia, The paper shows that there are problems in drawing comparisons abou
t migration and residential movement in Latin America and South Africa, but
that there are growing signs of similarity. Some of these similarities wer
e apparent even before the demise of apartheid, a policy that was never con
sistent and changed many times. The paper observes that South African migra
nts are becoming more like Latin Americans in demonstrating a growing attac
hment to the city. Many Sowetans' lives do not fit the model of the 'circul
ar' African migrant; many have lived in Johannesburg for a long time. Semi-
permanent residence means that residential movement within the city is incr
easingly similar to that typical in many Latin American cities. To judge fr
om Latin American experience, the dismantling of formal apartheid is unlike
ly to reduce levels of social segregation in Johannesburg, Rather, class di
visions will be just as effective as apartheid in guaranteeing residential
segregation.