CHARCOT-MARIE-TOOTH DISEASE TYPE-1A WITH 17P11.2 DUPLICATION - CLINICAL AND ELECTROPHYSIOLOGICAL PHENOTYPE STUDY AND INFLUENCING DISEASE SEVERITY IN 119 CASES
N. Birouk et al., CHARCOT-MARIE-TOOTH DISEASE TYPE-1A WITH 17P11.2 DUPLICATION - CLINICAL AND ELECTROPHYSIOLOGICAL PHENOTYPE STUDY AND INFLUENCING DISEASE SEVERITY IN 119 CASES, Brain, 120, 1997, pp. 813-823
A clinical and electrophysiological study was performed in 119 Type 1A
Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT1A) patients with proven 17p11.2 dupl
ication. Onset of the first functional manifestations was in the first
decade in 50% of cases and before the age of 20 years in 70% of cases
. The predominant clinical signs were muscle weakness and wasting in t
he lower limbs. None of the patients was normal on clinical examinatio
n and all presented at least pes cavus or ankle jerk areflexia. Motor
nerve conduction velocity (MNCV) was uniformly reduced in all nerves,
and was less than or equal to 33 m/s in the median nerve for all patie
nts. Sensory potentials were abnormal in all cases, even where there w
as no clinical sensory loss. Needle electromyography recruitment was r
educed in distal muscles for all patients. MNCV slowing was fully cons
istent with the presence of duplication even in clinically asymptomati
c individuals or in children, confirming the complete electrophysiolog
ical penetrance of 17p11.2 duplication and making median nerve MNCV a
reliable tool for screening affected at-risk individuals. Functional d
isability was mild. Ninety-six percent of patients were autonomous; 25
% were asymptomatic and diagnosed by systematic family investigation e
specially on the basis of median nerve MNCV reduction. Early age at on
set and greatly reduced median nerve MNCV were predictive of a more se
vere disease course; the earlier the onset the more reduced the median
nerve MNCV and the higher the functional disability tended to be afte
r an equivalent disease duration. Cross-sectional analysis of neurolog
ical deficit, functional deficit and MNCV according to disease duratio
n showed that, regardless of age at onset, CMT1A disease with 17p12.2
duplication is a clinically progressive disorder Neurological deficit
and functional disability increased, whereas median nerve MNCV and com
pound muscle action potential (CMAP) amplitude did not change with dis
ease course. Intrafamilial phenotype variation between parents and chi
ldren and between siblings was studied in large families. Functional d
isability and neurological deficit differed widely and the highest ran
ge of median nerve MNCV within a family reached 23 m/s. Clinical and e
lectrophysiological data were compared with those of CMT1B patients wi
th peripheral myelin Po protein point mutation. CMT1A patients were fo
und to be more severely affected with move prolonged distal motor late
ncy and more reduced CMAP amplitude, whereas MNCV did not significantl
y differ indicating that peripheral myelin Po protein point mutation i
s not always associated with a severe phenotype. The same genetic defe
ct (17p11.2 duplication) results in variable expression within the phe
notype, even in siblings with variations in age at onset, clinical sev
erity and MNCV slowing. This phenotypic variation could be due to addi
tional genetic factors related to peripheral myelin protein 22 express
ion as well as to other endogenous or environmental factors.