Pf. Foster et al., PREDICTION OF ABSTINENCE FROM ETHANOL IN ALCOHOLIC RECIPIENTS FOLLOWING LIVER-TRANSPLANTATION, Hepatology, 25(6), 1997, pp. 1469-1477
The prediction of abstinence horn ethanol may be crucial to the optima
l selection of liver transplantation candidates with alcoholism. Of 84
consecutive end stage alcoholic patients who underwent transplantatio
n (1986-1994) at our institution, we analyzed 63 long-surviving recipi
ents for pretransplantation variables to predict posttransplantation a
bstinence (follow-up: 49.3 +/- 21 mo). Thirty-three pretransplantation
variables were reviewed from our transplantation data base and supple
mented and confirmed with interviews with recipients. The psyche-socia
l inclusion criteria included the following: patient recognition of al
coholism, a domicile, an occupation, and at least one close personal r
elationship. The incidence of abstinence from ethanol was (50/63) 79%.
A logistic regression of the 33 variables in conjunction with our abo
ve inclusion criteria accurately predicted abstinence (90% accuracy, c
hi(2) model, P < .00001) based on the absence of previous history of a
ny illicit drug use (Drug Use: yes = 1/no = 0), the presence of an act
ive, personal life insurance policy (Life Ins: yes = line = 0), number
of alcoholic sisters (ETOH-SIS), and the length of pretransplantation
abstinence (PRE-TRANS-ABS, mos): Prob. of abstinence = 1/1 + e(-F), F
= -0.33 + 0.89 (DRUG USE) -1.02 (LIFE INS) -1.68 (ETOH-SIS) +0.24 (PR
E-TRANS-ABS). In contrast, receiver-operating characteristic curve ana
lysis found that 7 and 9 months of pretransplantation abstinence were
the best cut-off points in predicting subsequent abstinence, but poor
utility was noted at these points with this specific value alone (sens
itivity 61-84%, specificity 64-68%). A separate analysis of high-risk
patients with poly-drug use (n = 15, alcohol recidivism 8/15, 53%) and
the remaining low-risk group of purely alcohol dependent patients (n
= 48, alcohol recidivism 5/48, 10%) found no combination of variables
was predictive of abstinence in either group, The length of pretranspl
antation abstinence is a relatively poor predictor of posttransplantat
ion abstinence. Variables of comorbid substance use, social function,
and possibly family history are more predictive in conjunction with ou
r standard criteria and might be useful as tools in evaluating liver t
ransplantation candidates whose primary diagnosis is alcohol-induced c
irrhosis.