H. Luce et al., AN IMPROVED INTERPRETATION OF VHF OBLIQUE RADAR ECHOES BY A DIRECT BALLOON C-N(2) ESTIMATION USING A HORIZONTAL PAIR OF SENSORS, Radio science, 32(3), 1997, pp. 1261-1268
Successful comparisons between VHF oblique (15 degrees) radar echo pro
files and reconstructed ones deduced from high-resolution temperature
balloon measurements were presented by Luce et al. [1996]. The method
was based on the evaluation of the three-dimensional isotropic refract
ive index spectrum at the Bragg wavelength from the available temperat
ure profiles (''spectral method''). However, the isotropic hypothesis
is questionable, especially in regions where temperature sheets [Dalau
dier et al., 1994] are observed. Indeed, the associated anisotropic te
mperature fluctuations should contribute to the one-dimensional vertic
al temperature spectrum at small scales. In the present paper, another
method, less sensitive to anisotropic contaminations, is used. This m
ethod is based on an estimation of the temperature structure constant
C-T(2) from variances of horizontal differences of temperature measure
d by two high-resolution sensors 1 m apart horizontally (''horizontal
variance method''). It is shown that the main differences between the
C-T(2) estimations obtained from the two methods are mainly observed a
t high resolution in stable regions where few turbulent fluctuations i
n the temperature field are observed. However, the two methods give ap
proximately equivalent results at the radar range resolution (600 m) a
nd the quality of the comparisons with the radar observations is sligh
tly improved with the horizontal variance method. In order to demonstr
ate the full advantages of this technique, the use of radars with more
powerful capabilities is suggested for future investigations.