Mgb. Drew et al., Predicting ecotoxicology of organophosphorous insecticides: Successful parameter selection with the genetic function algorithm, QSAR, 18(6), 1999, pp. 573-583
QSARs have been developed for 20 organophosphates, using good experimental
data in the form of LC50 toxicity values towards guppy from previously publ
ished work. A large number of steric, physical and electronic descriptors h
ave been calculated. After the removal of descriptors that were highly cros
s-correlated or correlated poorly with activity, the genetic algorithm was
employed to select the optimum descriptors for use in multivariate regressi
on. Best equation r(2) and r(cv)(2) values were 0.943 and 0.905 respectivel
y. Molecular field Analysis was also used in conjunction with the Genetic F
unction Approximation (GFA) algorithm to obtain predictive equations, r(2)
and r(ev)(2) values were 0.939 and 0.896 respectively. However, when the da
ta were randomised, results proved to be as good, (and in one case better)
than using the correct experimental values. For equations subsequently deri
ved using the Genetic Partial Least Squares (G/PLS) technique (best r(2) an
d r(ev)(2) values being 0.943, 0.905 respectively), randomisation gave wors
e answers than using the correct experimental values. This work demonstrate
s the danger of using the powerful GFA technique to select from a large num
ber of parameters, but establishes that the G/PLS method is sufficiently ro
bust to provide reliable results.