Jh. Chern et al., USEFULNESS OF ARGYROPHILIC NUCLEOLAR ORGANIZER REGIONS SCORE TO DIFFERENTIATE SUSPICIOUS MALIGNANCY IN PULMONARY CYTOLOGY, Chest, 111(6), 1997, pp. 1591-1596
Objective: Pulmonary cytologic specimens reported as ''suspicious for
malignancy'' pose problems in clinical management, Silver staining for
argyrophilic nucleolar organizer regions (AgNOR) has proved useful in
making a cytopathologically differential diagnosis between benign and
malignant cells, This study aimed to evaluate the usefulness of AgNOR
score in the diagnosis of pulmonary cytologic specimens deemed inconc
lusive by conventional staining methods, Methods: Pulmonary cytologic
specimens initially reported as suspicious for malignancy with Papanic
olaou or May-Grunwald-Giemsa (MGG) staining obtained from 35 proved ca
ses were destained then restained using the AgNOR technique, Another 3
5 cases with clear cytologic diagnosis were also examined for comparis
on. The median number of dots, defined as the AgNOR score, mas used to
differentiate malignant from benign specimens. Results: Malignant cas
es had significantly higher AgNOR scores than benign ones (p < 0.001),
There were no significant differences among smears previously stained
with Papanicolaou or MGG method, among specimens obtained via broncho
scopic brushing, fine-needle aspiration of lung or pleural effusion, o
r among subgroups of malignant diseases. Based on the results of our p
revious study, the cutoff value of the AgNOR score to differentiate be
nignancy from malignancy was set at 6. At this setting, the sensitivit
y and specificity of AgNOR store were 88% and 80%, respectively, in ai
ding a differential diagnosis of pulmonary cytologic specimens initial
ly classified as suspicious for malignancy. For those cases with a cle
ar cytologic diagnosis, the sensitivity and specificity of AgNOR score
were 92% and 100%, respectively. For all cases, the sensitivity of Ag
NOR score was 90% and the specificity was also 90%. Conclusions: The A
gNOR score is of value in aiding a differential diagnosis between beni
gn and malignant lesions in pulmonary specimens with equivocal cytolog
ic features.