We retrospectively studied 17 cases of distal pectoralis major muscle ruptu
re to compare the results of repair in acute and chronic injuries and to co
mpare operative and nonoperative treatment. Thirteen patients underwent sur
gery (six acute injuries [less than 2 weeks after injury] and seven chronic
injuries) and four had nonoperative management. The mean age of the patien
ts at injury was 29, and 10 of the 17 injuries were the result of weight li
fting. Follow-up ranged from 18 months to 6 years (mean, 28 months). All pa
tients subjectively rated strength, pain, motion, function with strenuous s
porting activities, cosmesis, and overall satisfaction. Objectively, patien
ts were examined for range of motion, deformity, atrophy, and strength. Iso
kinetic strength testing was performed in eight patients: six treated opera
tively (three acute and three chronic) and two treated nonoperatively. Over
all subjective ratings were 96% in the acute group, 93% in the chronic grou
p, and only 51% in the nonoperative group. Isokinetic testing showed that p
atients operated on for acute injuries had the highest adduction strength (
102% of the opposite side) compared with patients with chronic injuries (94
%) or nonoperative treatment (71%), There were no statistically significant
subjective or objective differences in outcome between the patients treate
d operatively for acute or chronic injuries, but these patients fared signi
ficantly better than patients treated nonoperatively.