Ja. Stoughton et Wa. Marcus, Persistent impacts of trace metals from mining on floodplain grass communities along Soda Butte Creek, Yellowstone National Park, ENVIR MANAG, 25(3), 2000, pp. 305-320
In Yellowstone National Park, tailings and associated trace metals from pas
t mining have been deposited along 28 km of Soda Butte Creek by large flood
events. This study documents grass species diversity, density, and biomass
; trace metal concentrations in soils; and soil pH, salinity, and clay cont
ent in four selected floodplain meadows contaminated by these tailings. Tra
ce metal levels frequently exceed acceptable concentrations for agricultura
l soils at sampling points within the meadows. pH levels within flood-depos
ited tailings are strongly to moderately acid, while pH levels outside of t
ailings deposits are neutral. The data analysis: (1) shows that metals and
acidity associated with tailings affect plant biomass, density, and diversi
ty; (2) documents that the vegetation/metal and vegetation/pH associations
are more of a threshold than a linear relationship; and (3) suggests that o
ther factors may be involved in structuring the community. Vegetation diver
sity, density, and biomass decrease at threshold levels of trace metal conc
entrations and soil pH in all four meadows. CuSum plots of diversity in rel
ation to trace metal levels show a decrease in mean diversity at 315 ppm co
pper, 22 ppm arsenic, 4.2% iron, 65 ppm lead, and 170 ppm zinc. Densities o
f Phleum pratense and Poa pratensis were significantly lower(P less than or
equal to 0.001) on plots with more than 250 ppm copper. Above-ground bioma
ss of Phleum pratense was also significantly lower on plots with copper lev
els above 250 ppm. Decreased mean grass density was found on plots with pH
< 6.4, but the only statistically significant difference was for Juncus bal
ticus, which had increased density on plots with pH < 6.4. In contrast to t
he clear impacts of trace metals and pl-l on vegetation, other site charact
eristics did not alter measured vegetation characteristics.