C. Derouesne et al., Decreased awareness of cognitive deficits in patients with mild dementia of the Alzheimer type, INT J GER P, 14(12), 1999, pp. 1019-1030
Objective. To study the unawareness of cognitive deficits in patients with
mild dementia of Alzheimer type (DAT). Design. Retrospective study. We surv
eyed the medical records of outpatients meeting the NINCDS-ADRDA criteria f
or probable DAT who were able to complete the Cognitive Difficulties Scale
(CDS) and had a close informant relative (IR) who could complete the family
form of the same questionnaire.
Settings. A department of neurology in a general teaching hospital.
Subjects. Eighty-eight patients, aged 73.2 +/- 8.6 years with a mean MMSE s
core of 22.5 +/- 3.2. Fifty-two of the 88 patients had a follow-up examinat
ion after a mean interval of 21 months.
Methods. Awareness of cognitive deficits was mainly assessed as the differe
nce between the scores on the CDS completed by the IR and the patient (Inde
x of Unawareness, IU). Two secondary assessments of unawareness were perfor
med: (1) an assessment by the clinician on the basis of the patient's answe
rs to questions probing the awareness of memory deficits; (2) an evaluation
by the IR of the frequency of behavioural manifestations of unawareness in
everyday life. SPECT was performed in 78 patients to study the relationshi
p between unawareness and the topography of perfusion deficits.
Results. Awareness of the cognitive deficits varied greatly between patient
s, according to the assessment method used and the stage of progression of
the disease. Most patients with mild DAT were cognitively aware of their co
gnitive deficits but failed to appraise their severity and their consequenc
es in everyday life. Decreased awareness was positively correlated with age
and perfusion deficits in the frontal regions and negatively with the anxi
ous symptomatology. However, the main correlate of unawareness was apathy.
Conclusion. The nature of unawareness of cognitive deficits appeared to be
more dimensional than categorical. In patients with mild dementia, decrease
d awareness appeared to be more related to affective disturbances, especial
ly to emotional deficit or apathy, than to cognitive deficits. Copyright (C
) 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.