SOCIETE-DE-NEUROCHIRURGIE-DE-LANGUE-FRANC AISE, 47TH ANNUAL-MEETING, MARRAKECH, 25-28 1997 - NEUROSURGICAL TREATMENT OF PARKINSONS-DISEASE AND OTHER MOVEMENT-DISORDERS
J. Siegfried et al., SOCIETE-DE-NEUROCHIRURGIE-DE-LANGUE-FRANC AISE, 47TH ANNUAL-MEETING, MARRAKECH, 25-28 1997 - NEUROSURGICAL TREATMENT OF PARKINSONS-DISEASE AND OTHER MOVEMENT-DISORDERS, Neuro-chirurgie, 43, 1997, pp. 7
The present work is intended by its two principal authors as an exposi
tion of the role of neurosurgery in the treatment of Parkinson's disea
se and, additionally, in the treatment of other movement disorders. Th
e first chapter is devoted to a discussion of the long history of func
tional neurosurgery for movement disorders, which remains a source of
valuable insights today. The field grew remarkably rapidly in the year
s following the introduction of stereotaxy in 1947, and, after a slowe
r period, received an important new impulse within the past decade. Mo
st of the procedures discussed were developed empirically, in that the
scientific explanations of their success (or failure) have usually ar
rived a posteriori. Nonetheless, our present knowledge of the underlyi
ng physiologic and biochemical mechanisms is considerable. Drs. Parent
and Cicchetti have, therefore, assumed the task of reviewing this kno
wledge with reference to the most recently published data. Jean Paul F
rancke and collaborators provide an up-to-date review of the anatomy o
f the thalamus and basal ganglia which deserves the attention of all n
eurosurgeons, as des the review of functional imaging by Olivier Rasco
l and collaborators, which explains the importance of these new techni
ques for the measurement and visual display of physiologic data. Final
ly, Alain Destee takes us back to the clinic and reminds us once again
of the role of the neurologist in providing conservative (i.e., non-s
urgical) treatment for Parkinson's disease. The emphasis on basic neur
oscience in the first few chapters is perhaps unexpected in a neurosur
gical text. We have included this non-clinical material to show that t
he approach to Parkinson's disease involves specialists in many discip
lines, and that an understanding of underlying mechanisms is indispens
able. This book is intended, not only for neurosurgeons, but for all p
hysicians who treat patients with Parkinson's disease. We have prepare
d an English translation, published simultaneously with the French ori
ginal, to help it reach the widest possible audience. The two principa
l authors believe that neurosurgery has a role in the treatment of Par
kinson's disease to the extent that it is simple? safe, effective, and
non-traumatic to the patient. Ablative and non-destructive methods ar
e reviewed. The procedures should thus be performed under local anesth
esia, and should be as short as possible, to cause the patient minimal
discomfort. In their view, intraoperative stereotactic ventriculograp
hy obviates the need to transfer the patient to and from the magnetic
resonance suite with the frame attached, and thereby shortens the proc
edure, without impairing the surgical result; this aspect has been dis
cussed at further length in the chapter entitled ''Stereotactic Method
s''. For similar reasons, microor macrocellular recording are not perf
ormed. In this work, the two principal authors have described anew the
uses of a number of neurosurgical procedures once thought absolete. T
hey have oriented themselve resolutely toward a simple and pragmatic a
pproach centered entirely on the patient, with the single purpose of i
mproving his quality of life. Their conclusions will undoubtely arouse
criticism, which can only be beneficial. Nonetheless, the experience
has convinced the authors that they have made the correct choices. The
y hope this work will help popularize these techniques so that the gre
atest possible number of patients can be helped. This is not an exhaus
tive study. A greater stress on possible future therapies could have b
een placed; instead, they have merely skimmed over them. It is always
presumptuous to predict the future, even for visionaries. This report
is meant to summarize the state of the art, as of 1996, in the neurosu
rgical treatment of Parkinson's disease and other movement disorders.
The authors expect the ingenuity of our peers to yield entirely new ap
proaches in the years to come. The ultimate treatment will be, not neu
rosurgical, but preventive, and will be given before manifestations of
disease ever appear. The constant progress of medical science allows
us to think this hope is not utopian.