OBJETIVE: Two dietary regimens recommended for the reduction of coronary ri
sk, by way of their effects on lipid profile, are the diet low in saturated
fat and a diet rich in monounsaturated fats (MUFA). However the effects of
these diets on carbohydrate metabolism in healthy subjects are not well kn
own. The objetive of this study was to compare the effect of both diets on
various parameters of carbohydrate metabolism.
METHODS: 41 healthy young males were submitted to 3 consecutive diets, each
for a duration of 4 weeks. The first diet was rich in saturated fat (SAT)
(38% fat, 20% saturated). The second was rich in carbohydrates following th
e recommendations of the NCEP-1 (National Cholesterol Education Program typ
e 1) (28% fat, 47% carbohydrates). The last one was a diet rich in monounsa
turated fatty acids (38% fat, 22% MUFA). At the end of each dietary period,
blood presure (BP) and blood levels of glucose, insulin and free fatty aci
ds were determined. 29 subjects were also submitted to an oral glucose tole
rance test (OGTT) at the end of each diet.
RESULTS: The SAT diet induced the highest levels of insulin after the OGTT.
The consumption of the MUFA diet determined the lowest levels of fasting b
lood glucose (-0.60 mmol/l [13%], p < 0.0002), insulin (-9 mu UI/ml [47%],
p < 0.0002) and free fatty acids (-0.11 mmol/l [24%], p = 0.006), compared
to the NCEP-1 diet. Systolic and diastolic blood presure were higher in the
NCEP-1 diet than during the other periods (SBP: +6 mmHg compare with SAT [
5%], p = 0.0001; and +5 mmHg compare with MUFA [4%], p = 0.0001; DBP: +20 m
mHg compare with MUFA [27%], p = 0.0001) and +6 mmHg compared with SAT [8%]
, p = 0.0001).
CONCLUSION: Of the diets most commonly used for the treatment and preventio
n of arteriosclerosis, a diet rich in monounsaturated fats is the most bene
ficial for the healthy population from the point of view of carbohydrate me
tabolism and blood presure.