The stability of the aromatic phase of two-dimensional monolayers of BN, C,
Si, GaAs, and SiC is theoretically investigated using an nb initio tight-b
inding-like method. It is found that BN, C, and SIC prefer to form the hat
aromatic phase while Si and GaAs prefer to pucker, although Si is found to
be a borderline case. From a simple qualitative picture, we can understand
this behaviour as a consequence of the different bond lengths, where longer
bond lengths give rise to puckered structures. On the other hand, 'compres
sing chemically' by alloying, which shortens the bond, may allow the state
of the system to change from puckered to flat and vice versa.