S. Herrero et al., Nucleocapsid gene-mediated transgenic resistance provides protection against Tomato spotted wilt virus epidemics in the field, PHYTOPATHOL, 90(2), 2000, pp. 139-147
Transformation of plants with the nucleocapsid (N) gene of Tomato sported w
ilt tospovirus (TSWV) provides resistance to disease development; however,
information is lacking on the response of plants to natural inoculum in the
field. Three tobacco cultivars were transformed with the N gene of a dahli
a isolate of TSWV (TSWV-D), and plants were evaluated over several generati
ons in the greenhouse. The resistant phenotype was more frequently observed
in 'Burley 21' than in 'KY-14' or 'K-326', but highly resistant 'Burley 21
' transgenic lines were resistant to only 44% of the heterologous TSWV isol
ates tested. Advanced generation (R-3 and R-4) transgenic resistant lines o
f 'Burley 21' and a 'K-326' F-1 hybrid containing the N genes of two TSWV i
solates were evaluated in the field near Tifton, GA, where TSWV is endemic.
Disease development was monitored by symptom expression and enzyme-linked
immunosorbent assay (ELISA) analysis. Whereas incidence of TSWV infection i
n 'Burley 21' susceptible controls was 20% in 1996 and 62% in 1997, the mea
n incidence in transgenic lines was reduced to 4 and 31%, respectively. Thr
ee transgenic 'Burley 21' lines were identified that had significantly lowe
r incidence of disease than susceptible controls over the two years of the
study. In addition, the rate of disease increase at the onset of the 1997 e
pidemic was reduced for all the 'Burley 21' transgenic lines compared with
the susceptible controls. The 'K-326' F-1 hybrid was as susceptible as the
'K326' nontransformed control. ELISA analysis demonstrated that symptomless
plants from the most resistant 'Burley 21' transgenic lines accumulated de
tectable nucleocapsid protein, whereas symptomless plants from more suscept
ible lines did not. We conclude that transgenic resistance to TSWV is effec
tive in reducing incidence of the disease in the field, and that accumulati
on of transgene protein may be important in broad-spectrum resistance.