Po. Heinonen et al., VALIDATION OF AIR TONOMETRIC MEASUREMENT OF GASTRIC REGIONAL CONCENTRATIONS OF CO2 IN CRITICALLY-ILL SEPTIC PATIENTS, Intensive care medicine, 23(5), 1997, pp. 524-529
Objective: To evaluate the accuracy of continuous air tonometry (Tonoc
ap, Tonometric Division, Instrumentarium, Helsinki, Finland). Design:
The accuracy of air tonometry was tested by comparing it with conventi
onal saline tonometry in mechanically ventilated, critically ill septi
c patients and in vitro determining the partial pressure of carbon dio
xide (PCO2) of humidified gases with known concentrations of CO2. Sett
ing: A mixed intensive care unit in a university hospital. Patients: 1
6 mechanically ventilated patients with sepsis. Measurements and resul
ts: Two gastric tonometer catheters (TRIP NGS catheter, Tonometric Div
ision, Instrumentarium, Helsinki, Finland) were introduced into the pa
tients' stomachs. The control catheter was used as a conventional sali
ne tonometer and the other catheter was used with the Tonocap monitori
ng device. A total of 153 paired measurements was made and analysed ac
cording to Bland and Altman. The mean difference between air PCO2 and
saline PCO2 values (bias), the standard deviation of the differences (
precision), and the Pearson correlation coefficient between air PCO2 a
nd saline PCO2 were calculated. The data on patients were pooled and c
alculated for different cycle times. The mean bias (kPa) was -0.02 wit
h a 10-min cycle time, 0.31 with 15 min, 0.56 with 30 min and 0.21 wit
h 60-min. The precisions were 0.39, 0.54, 0.44 and 0.76, respectively.
Pearson correlation coefficients were 0.93, 0.97, 0.95 and 0.82, resp
ectively (p < 0.0001). In vitro tonometry with the Tonocap was perform
ed in a gas chamber fully saturated with known CO2 concentrations. The
clinically important 10-min cycle time was tested with 5 Tonocap moni
tors. Except for the first 10-min cycle time, PCO2 values determined b
y the Tonocap monitoring systems were comparable to known CO2 concentr
ations. Conclusions: The accuracy of Tonocap continuous air tonometry
is close to that of conventional saline tonometry. Moreover, the clini
cally important 10-min cycle time with air tonometry correlated very w
ell with saline tonometry and the time response with air tonometry was
short.