P. Rougier et al., Established data and practical recommendations for neoadjuvant and adjuvant chemotherapy for rectal cancer., ANN CHIR, 53(10), 1999, pp. 1011-1018
Adjuvant chemotherapy appears to be active in stage II-III rectal cancers;
the NSAPB R01 trial demonstrated a survival advantage for patients receivin
g chemotherapy using the MOF protocol and 3 metaanalyses are in favor of th
e efficacy of adjuvant chemotherapy in rectal cancer. Three randomized tria
ls have also demonstrated that combinations of radiation and chemotherapy a
re superior to surgery alone or adjuvant radiotherapy and demonstrated the
major role of systemic chemotherapy combined with radiotherapy. However thi
s efficacy of adjuvant chemotherapy alone or combined with radiation therap
y is still debated and specific trials must be conducted to test the value
of chemotherapy using more active regimens than those previously tested and
taking into account the quality of surgery and radiotherapy; such trials a
re in progress, especially the trial conducted by the EORTC and the FFCD. T
he efficacy of neoadjuvant chemotherapy has never been clearly demonstrated
, although a combination of radiotherapy and chemotherapy as first-line tre
atment for locally advanced rectal cancer and in the case of synchronous me
tastasis seems to facilitate surgical resection. It is a reasonable and tol
erable approach with manageable toxicity which gives substantial results in
2/3 of patients. This strategy also allows better selection of patients li
kely to benefit from surgical resection of their primary tumor and in some
cases of their synchronous metastases. However, the efficacy of perioperati
ve treatments should not decrease the quality of the surgical resection and
especially mesorectal excision as well as the need for high quality pathol
ogical examination which must be very thorough with analysis of a sufficien
t number of lymph nodes. The efficacy of combined treatment in advanced rec
tal cancers is a major argument in favor of the multidisciplinary coordinat
ion required for optimal treatment of patients with rectal cancer.