G. Fox et al., Estimating the value of precipitation forecast information in alfalfa dry hay production in Ontario, J PROD AGR, 12(4), 1999, pp. 551-558
The value of weather forecast information to farmers is an important compon
ent of program evaluation of weather information systems. No empirical stud
ies have attempted to provide this kind of information for Canadian produce
rs. In this study, a farm level production economics model was used to char
acterize the value of precipitation forecast information to alfalfa (Medica
go sativa L.) dry hay producers in the province of Ontario. This model was
applied to precipitation forecast data from the Windsor and the London Envi
ronment Canada weather offices for the crop years of 1994 and 1995. Four fo
recast methods are compared. Precipitation damage relationships during harv
est are estimated using an agronomic simulation model combined with expert
opinion. The value of weather forecast information was found to vary consid
erably between 1994 and 1995. For the region served by the London Ontario w
eather station, our results indicate that the Environment Canada daily prec
ipitation forecast was worth $30.23 (Cdn)/acre in 1994 and $26.39 (Cdn)/acr
e in 1995. For the region served by the Waterloo weather station, the 1994
forecast was worth $36.08/acre. In contrast, producers: who followed the 19
95 forecast would have been worse off by $5.72 (Cdn)/acre relative to what
they would have been able to earn by naively assuming that precipitation ov
er the next 4 d would be the same as the last 4 d. The level of risk aversi
on of the producer was not found to be an important determinant of the valu
e of weather forecast information. Averages of the range of values of weath
er forecast information obtained in this study indicate that precipitation
forecast information is of considerable value to producers at critical time
s in the production process for alfalfa dry hay.