Management intensive rotational grazing (MIRG) is an expanding practice amo
ng dairy farmers in the Upper Midwest. Despite the high productivity associ
ated with MIRG pastures, many acres of unmanaged, continuously grazed pastu
res still exist. Our goal was to document relationships between forage grow
th, production, and quality in rotational and continuous grazing systems an
d to evaluate the role that management plays in the productivity of these p
astures. Forages were monitored under farmer management on three MIRG dairy
farms and on three continuously grazed pastures (CON) on conventional live
stock farms in 1994 and 1995. Evaluation of the results was complicated by
the range of conditions and management practices that characterized the stu
dy's participants. As is typical for this region, CON pastures in this stud
y were unmanaged. In contrast, MIRG pastures were monitored daily by their
owners and sward health was maintained through movement of the herd and suc
h practices as interseeding legumes. Forage mass for MIRG pastures was grea
ter than CON every week of the 24-wk grazing season, averaging 1763 lb/acre
for ready-to-graze MIRG paddocks vs. 850 lb/acre for CON. Crude protein av
eraged 16.6% for MIRG vs. 15.3% for CON. Seasonal average ADF values were 3
4.2% for MIRG and 34.1% for CON. Average NDF values were 53.4% for MIRG and
56.8% for CON. Forage mass between 1300 and 1900 lb/acre appeared to provi
de a balance between yield and quality on MIRG pastures. Cooperating farmer
s most often chose to graze paddocks at this level. For CON, forage quality
decreased as forage biomass increased. Ready-to-graze MIRG paddocks had si
gnificantly higher quality than CON pastures at equivalent levels of forage
biomass. It was not possible in this study to isolate individual managemen
t practices and test them separately, so no one factor can be viewed as res
ponsible for the differences we observed. Indeed, these differences probabl
y are the result of the interaction among several management practices on M
IRG farms and the lack of pasture management on CON farms.