H. Qian et al., Phytogeographical and community similarities of alpine tundras of Changbaishan Summit, China, and Indian Peaks, USA, J VEG SCI, 10(6), 1999, pp. 869-882
We compared the diversity, phytogeography, and plant communities in two mid
-latitude alpine tundras with comparable aerial and elevational extents: Ch
angbaishan Summit in eastern Asia and Indian Peaks in western North America
. Despite wide separation, the two areas shared 72 species. In all, 43 % of
the species on Changbaishan Summit are also distributed in the alpine zone
s of western North America, while 22 % of the species on Indian Peaks are a
lso distributed in the alpine zones of eastern Asia. Almost all the shared
species also occur in the Beringian region. Phytogeographical profiles of s
pecies and genera showed that 69 % of species and over 90 % of genera in bo
th alpine tundras belong to the three phytogeographical categories: cosmopo
litan, circumpolar, and Asian-North American. We attributed the current flo
ristic relationship between these widely separated areas to the periodic pa
st land connection between the two continents during the Tertiary and Pleis
tocene. Indian Peaks has a closer floristic relationship with the Arctic tu
ndra than does Changbaishan Summit. Indian Peaks also has 45 % higher speci
es richness and lower vegetation cover than Changbaishan Summit.
Plant communities from the two areas were completely separated in the two-w
ay indicator species analysis and nonmetric multidimensional scaling on flo
ristic data at both species and generic levels, whereas ordination of commu
nities by soil data produced a greater overlap. The plant communities on Ch
angbaishan Summit in general have lower alpha diversity, higher beta divers
ity (lower between-community floristic similarity), and more rare species t
han does Indian Peaks. Mosaic diversity does not differ in the two alpine t
undras, although the analysis suggests that Changbaishan Summit communities
are more widely spaced on gradients than the Indian Peaks communities.