M. Leach et J. Fairhead, Fashioned forest pasts, occluded histories? International environmental analysis in West African locales, DEVELOP CHA, 31(1), 2000, pp. 35-59
This article considers how environmental problematics are produced and inte
rpreted, using case material from West Africa's humid forest zone. framing
the experiences of several countries over the long term, it is possible to
identify a deforestation discourse produced through national and internatio
nal institutions. This represents forest and social history in particular w
ays that structure forest conservation but which obscure the experience and
knowledge of resource users. Using fine-grained ethnography to explore how
such discourse is experienced and interpreted in a particular locale, the
article uncovers problems with 'discourse' perspectives which produce analy
tical dichotomies which confront state and villager, and scientific and 'lo
cal' knowledges. The authors explore the day-to-day encounters between vill
agers and administrators, and the social and historical experiences which c
ondition these. Instances where the deforestation discourse becomes juxtapo
sed with villagers' alternative ideas about landscape history prove relativ
ely few and insignificant, while the powerful material effects of the disco
urse tend to be interpreted locally within other frames. These findings pre
sent departures from the ways relations between citizen sciences and expert
institutions have been conceived in recent work on the sociology of scienc
e and public policy.