Ps. Thenkabail et al., Hyperspectral vegetation indices and their relationships with agriculturalcrop characteristics, REMOT SEN E, 71(2), 2000, pp. 158-182
The objective of this paper is to determine spectral bands that are best su
ited for characterizing agricultural crop biophysical variables. The data f
or this study comes from ground-level hyperspectral reflectance measurement
s of cotton, potato, soybeans, corn, and sunflower. Reflectance was measure
d in 490 discrete narrow bands between 350 and 1,050 nm. Observed crop char
acteristics included wet biomass, leaf area index, plant height, and (for c
otton only) yield. Three types of hyperspectral predictors were tested: opt
imum multiple narrow band reflectance (OMNBR), narrow band normalized diffe
rence vegetation index (NDVI) involving all possible two-band combinations
of 490 channels, and the soil-adjusted vegetation indices. A critical probl
em with OMNBR models was that of "over fitting" (i.e., using more spectral
channels than experimental samples to obtain a highly maximum R-2 value). T
his problem was addressed by comparing the R-2 values of crop variables wit
h the R-2 values computed for random data of a large sample size. The combi
nations of two to four narrow bands in OMNBR models explained most (64% to
92%) of the variability in crop biophysical variables. The second part of t
he paper describes a rigorous search procedure to identify the best narrow
band NDVI predictors of crop biophysical variables. Special narrow band lam
bda (lambda(1)) versus lambda (lambda(2)) plots of R-2 values illustrate th
e most effective wavelength combinations (lambda(1) and lambda(2)) and band
widths (Delta lambda(1) and Delta lambda(2)) for predicting the biophysical
quantities of each crop. The best of these two-band indices were further t
ested to see if soil adjustment or nonlinear fitting could improve their pr
edictive accuracy. The best of the narrow band NDVI models explained 64% to
88% variability in different crop biophysical variables. A strong relation
ship with crop characteristics is located in specific narrow bands in the l
onger wavelength portion of the red (650 to 700 nm), with secondary cluster
s in the shorter wavelength portion of green (500 nm to 550 nm), in one par
ticular section of the near-infrared (900 nm to 940 nm), and in the moistur
e sensitive near-infrared (centered at 982 nm). This study recommends a 12
narrow band sensor, in the 350 nm to 1,050 nm range of the spectrum, for op
timum estimation of agricultural crop biophysical information. (C) Elsevier
Science Inc., 2000.