We compared the predictions of the single path convection-diffusion model (
SPM) and the well-mixed single acinus model (SAM) with the normalized slope
s (NS) of experimentally measured volumetric capnograms in which VT was var
ied in three healthy spontaneously breathing adults. For values of VT great
er than 15 ml/kg, the tidal volume penetrates deep into the acinar airways,
mixing by molecular diffusion is rapid and the predictions of the SAM and
SPM both agree with the experiment. The SPM however shows much better agree
ment with the experimental NS data than does the SAM for values of VT less
than 10 ml/kg. The explanation for the departure of the SAM from the observ
ed experimental data, at small VT, is that it represents the limiting case
(of well-mixed alveolar gas) for the SPM, only at large VT, where the assum
ption of rapid mixing is most accurate. We conclude that in general, gas ph
ase diffusivity and total acinar airway cross sectional area variation with
cumulative volume into the lung are essential to realistically model airwa
y gas exchange between VT and FRC and to obtain agreement with experimental
data under the widest range of breathing conditions. (C) 2000 Elsevier Sci
ence B.V. All rights reserved.