A. Ringvall et G. Stahl, On the field performance of transect relascope sampling for assessing downed coarse woody debris, SC J FOR R, 14(6), 1999, pp. 552-557
Transect relascope sampling is a recently proposed method for making effici
ent inventories of coarse woody debris on the ground. However, before the m
ethod call be recommended, its performance in the field requires investigat
ion. This paper presents the results of a field study in which 11 surveyors
tested the method in two coniferous stands in northern Sweden. The average
bias introduced by the surveyors was moderate under normal sighting condit
ions, but underestimation was substantial when combining a small relascope
angle with poor sighting conditions. In all cases, the differences between
the systematic errors of individual surveyors were substantial. The conclus
ion is that transect relascope sampling is not an appropriate method when t
he demand for unbiased estimates is high, e.g. in connection with long-term
monitoring, but that the method can be useful as a first phase in double s
ampling or in ocular-based inventories aimed at identifying biologically va
luable areas.