F. Papin et al., Reporting of resected colonic carcinomas. Assessment of practices in 8 French counties in 1995., GASTRO CL B, 23(12), 1999, pp. 1360-1367
Objectives - The objective of this work was to study the reporting of resec
ted colonic carcinomas and to compare them with Consensus Guidelines publis
hed in January 1998.
Methods - The study included 535 colonic carcinomas collected in 8 French r
egistries in 1995, and chosen by drawing lots. For each report, the presenc
e of the information requested by the Guidelines was looked for. Three synt
hetic variables were built: 2 scores and one qualitative at 2 classes. The
influence of patients, tumour and health care system's characteristics was
analyzed on the 3 dependent variables.
Results - Some important variations were observed for information's percent
s in reporting. In monovariate analysis, scores were significantly influenc
ed by cancer's sub-location, aera of patient's residence, surgical center,
type of laboratories and pathologist case volume. In multivariate analysis,
significant heterogeneity in practices remained between geographical aeras
. Type of laboratories and pathologist case volume affected differently dep
endent variables.
Conclusion - This study shows the necessity to assess the practices before
consensus because of the impact of pathological forms in therapeutic decisi
ons and variations observed.