A. Leurdijk, COMMON-SENSE VERSUS POLITICAL DISCOURSE - DEBATING RACISM AND MULTICULTURAL SOCIETY IN DUTCH TALK SHOWS, European journal of communication, 12(2), 1997, pp. 147-168
In the past few years a considerable amount of literature has appeared
concerning talk shows, in particular those with active participation
of studio audiences. The evaluation of these shows in the light of the
ir contribution to mediated public debates, varies from praise for pre
sumed postmodern qualities to utter condemnation for their trivializat
ion of everything deemed serious. This article confronts these views w
ith an analysis of Dutch audience discussion shows dealing with racism
and a multicultural society. The main question is in what ways do aud
ience discussion shows offer a forum for public debate on racism and a
multicultural society in the Netherlands! This question is answered b
y looking at the numbers of white and ethnic minority participants and
the perspectives included in the debates. The article also tries to e
stablish the impact of characteristics of the genre on the debates. Th
e results indicate that talk shows have some potential for offering un
expected, controversial and oppositional perspectives from ethnic mino
rity groups.