The frequent occurrence of depressive symptoms in patients with borderline
personality disorder has generated considerable interest in the nature of t
he relationship between borderline personality disorder and the depressive
disorders. Data from the perspectives of phenomenology, biology, family his
tory, course of illness, comorbidity patterns, and treatment response have
been bought to bear on the question. Reviews based on research available by
1985 and 1991, respectively, arrived at differing conclusions: (1) that bo
th disorders shared common but non-specific sources, and (2) that the two d
isorders were unrelated but co-occurred because of the high prevalence of e
ach. Since the time of these reviews, additional evidence has become availa
ble from a wider range of biological investigations, better controlled como
rbidity studies, studies of the relationship of psychosocial stressors to t
he course of each disorder and neuroimaging studies. In reviewing the more
recent findings, we propose the less parsimonious hypothesis that the disor
ders co-occur, both because they share some common biological features and
because the psychosocial sequella of each can contribute to the development
of the other. Published 1999 Wiley-Liss, Inc.