Sudden-onset asthma exacerbations may have different triggers and responses
to treatment than slower-onset exacerbations. The authors studied this hyp
othesis among patients with severe asthma exacerbations.
The Multicenter Airway Research Collaboration prospectively enrolled patien
ts presenting to 64 North American emergency departments with asthma exacer
bations. Of 1,847 patients aged 18-54 yrs, 900 had severe exacerbations (pe
ak expiratory flow rate (PEFR) <50% predicted or hospitalized without PEFR)
, These patients were divided into sudden-onset (less than or equal to 3 h
of symptoms) and slower-onset (>3 h of symptoms) groups.
Fourteen per cent (95% confidence interval, 11-16%) of patients with severe
asthma exacerbations had sudden-onset exacerbations. Sudden-onset patients
were similar to slower-onset patients, except triggers of their exacerbati
ons were more often respiratory allergens, exercise or psychosocial stress
and less often respiratory infections. Sudden-onset patients were more like
ly to have used oral beta-agonists and salmeterol in the preceding 1 weeks.
Although initial PEFRs and management were similar, sudden-onset patients
had a greater improvement in PEFR (35 versus 28% p<0.001), Sudden-onset pat
ients were less often discharged on systemic corticosteroids, but had simil
ar 2-week relapse rates compared with slower-onset patients,
Among patients presenting with severe asthma exacerbations, sudden-onset ex
acerbations had a different pattern of triggers and greater improvement wit
h treatment than slower-onset exacerbations.