L. Kroger et al., Development of tuberculin reactivity and sensitization to M. Scrofulaceum and M. Fortuitum in children BCG-vaccinated at birth, EUR RESP J, 15(2), 2000, pp. 382-387
Since the incidence of tuberculosis is steadily declining in Finland and in
fections by environmental mycobacteria may be increasing, the aim of the pr
esent study was to evaluate the development of tuberculin reactivity and se
nsitization to environmental mycobacteria,
Healthy Finnish schoolchildren aged 10.4-12.4 yrs (n=201) were tested with
tuberculin purified protein derivative RT23, Mycobacterium scrofulaceum RS9
5 and M. fortuitum RS20 sensitins, The same children had been previously te
sted with the same antigens and methods at the age of 4-6 yrs in 1989. Rapi
d waning of tuberculin reactivity and decrease in sensitization to environm
ental mycobacteria were observed between 4-6 yrs.
Both tuberculin and sensitin skin reaction sizes decreased significantly ov
er the 6-yrs period. The mean tuberculin skin reaction size was 3.2 mm in d
iameter, which was significantly (p<0.001) smaller than the mean induration
size (4.8 mm) at the age of 4-6 yrs. Similarly, the mean skin reaction siz
es to M. scrofulaceum and M. fortuitum sensitins were 3.4 and 1.7 mm, respe
ctively, which were significantly (p<0.001) smaller than 6 yrs earlier (mea
n 4.5 and 3.1 mm), The number of zero reactions to all antigens increased s
ignificantly during the follow-up period. Contacts with pets or farm animal
s were associated with larger reactions. In contrast, children suffering fr
om allergic symptoms had smaller reactions.
Contacts with mycobacteria, either with Mycobacterium tuberculosis or envir
onmental mycobacteria, seem to be too rare to maintain tuberculin responsiv
eness and a high sensitivity to other mycobacteria. Different bacille Calme
tte-Guerin vaccine products and dosages used, the declining incidence of tu
berculosis and geographical factors, which can influence environmental myco
bacterial exposure, may explain the disparity between the present and previ
ous Finnish studies.