Background: In 1933 in Leon, Nicaragua, a 22-year-old woman died after an a
cute convulsive illness in which she experienced trismus, opisthotonos, and
hyperpyrexia. Three years later her husband, Oliverio Castaneda, was convi
cted of her murder and that of 2 other people in the same city. Methods: We
went to Nicaragua to investigate documents involved with that case and eva
luate whether the verdict of murder by strychnine was substantiated by the
data. We present the results of the investigation and provide information a
bout the practice of medicine, pharmacy, and toxicology early in this centu
ry. Results: The clinical picture in all 3 cases suggests strychnine poison
ing. The clinical, toxicological, and circumstantial evidence is strong and
implicates Castaneda as a murderer and strychnine as the weapon. Conclusio
n: We conclude that Oliverio Castaneda was the probable perpetrator of thre
e 1933 strychnine murders in Leon and that he may have previously used stry
chnine to kill others in Nicaragua and neighboring countries.