This experimental study examined whether problem-oriented study texts resul
t in learning that allows a broader application of the acquired knowledge s
uch that it can be used to solve other problems. A group receiving structur
e-oriented instruction and a control group were compared with subjects who
had been given problem-oriented instruction. With regard to problem-solving
tasks, it became apparent that the problem-oriented students were superior
in a significant and relevant way to the comparison groups. However, there
were no differences between the structure-oriented group and the control g
roup. The group that received problem-oriented instruction did not perform
more poorly on an additional test with knowledge tasks. Consequences arise
for practical application, as do questions about the generalization of the
results.