Patients seek psychotherapy for relief of symptoms and resolution of proble
ms tit living. Yet, they sometimes balk at the prospect of having to choose
a topic without being prompted by, therapist questions. This paper suggest
s that this apparently self-sabotaging behavior represents an acting out of
a fundamental existential dilemma for many individuals, i.e., to be or not
to be an adult. Adulthood comes with the heavy burden of responsibility fo
r making life choices, and the possibility of making the wrong choices. The
psychotherapeutic situation, with ifs demand that the patient choose a top
ic, is a microcosm of the adult-adult relationship. The author proposes tha
t the proper treatment for these patients is Generative Caring Psychotherap
y, which promotes emotional growth and facilitates patients' transition fro
m childhood dependence to adult responsibility.