Despite the frequency with which they have been promoted as a model of deve
lopment, East Asian trade policies have had little influence on the normati
ve economics of trade reform. In contrast to directly dismantling protectio
n, developing countries have often provided concessional import rights whic
h override existing protection. These instruments include EPZs and duty rem
ission. This paper accommodates these instruments of 'new trade liberalizat
ion' within a more general understanding of trade liberalization illustrati
ng their similarities and their differences. Both old and new trade liberal
ization can, on their own, bring about complete free trade. Needless to say
, so far, neither has.