Bl. Peckarsky et al., EXTRAPOLATING FROM INDIVIDUAL BEHAVIOR TO POPULATIONS AND COMMUNITIESIN STREAMS, Journal of the North American Benthological Society, 16(2), 1997, pp. 375-390
Biological processes, such as predator-prey or competitive interaction
s, occur at multiple spatial and temporal scales, but their impacts on
the distribution, abundance and fitness of organisms may only be dete
ctable at some scales. This is because 1) small scale (local) processe
s may be constrained by large-scale (regional) processes, 2) the influ
ence of organism movement changes with spatial scale, and 3) multiple
small-scale processes may interact and produce variation that obscures
large-scale patterns. Most ecologists would like to know the relevanc
e of small-scale observations and experiments for large-scale patterns
and processes acting over long time periods. In this paper we conside
r whether patterns of individual behavior translate in a straightforwa
rd way to patterns in population dynamics, community structure or indi
vidual fitness at larger spatial and longer temporal scales. We illust
rate our discussion with data from communities living in high altitude
streams in western Colorado, coastal streams in southern California,
and streams on the South Island of New Zealand. We describe patterns o
f individual behavior including selective predation, predator-avoidanc
e behavior, and competitive interactions. Our examples indicate that l
arge scale patterns of distribution and abundance of organisms sometim
es deviate from those expected from patterns of individual behavior. W
e hypothesize that such discrepancies are often due to multiple confou
nding factors, including abiotic disturbances, that have effects on po
pulations and communities at larger scales. Similarly, our data illust
rate that present behaviors may not have measurable fitness consequenc
es over longer time scales. We emphasize that only by studying all lif
e history stages of organisms with complex life cycles can we interpre
t the long-term fitness consequences of individual behaviors. We concl
ude that our ability to extrapolate from individual behaviors to popul
ations and communities in streams will improve when we consider the re
percussions of individual behaviors and environmental factors over bro
ader spatial and temporal scales.