Jx. Guinard et al., Consumer testing of commercial lager beers in blind versus informed conditions: Relation with descriptive analysis and expert quality ratings, J I BREWING, 106(1), 2000, pp. 11-19
American beer consumers (n=170) evenly distributed into six categories base
d on age (20s, 30s, 40s) and gender, tasted 24 commercial, domestic/ice, im
ported and speciality lagers first blind (week 1) and then with knowledge o
f brand and price (week 2). They rated overall degree of liking (DOL) and D
OL of the appearance, carbonation, aroma, taste, body/mouthfeel and afterta
ste of the beer on a 9-point hedonic scale, and purchase intent (PI) on a 5
-point scale, and indicated in which situation they would consume the beers
. Relationships between consumer ratings and descriptive analysis and quali
ty ratings by brewing experts were then analysed with multivariate statisti
cs.
Gender differences were observed, with men preferring stronger-flavoured be
ers (speciality > imported > domestic) regardless of quality, whereas women
's hedonic ratings paralleled expert quality ratings. DOL and PI ratings of
some domestic and imported beers decreased and increased respectively, fro
m the blind to the informed condition, suggesting American consumers view i
mported beers as superior products, even though blind tasting suggested oth
erwise. In all age and gender groups, liking for taste was the best predict
or of overall liking.