The peer-review system: time for re-assessment?

Citation
Hu. Riisgard et al., The peer-review system: time for re-assessment?, MAR ECOL-PR, 192, 2000, pp. 305-313
Citations number
3
Categorie Soggetti
Aquatic Sciences
Journal title
MARINE ECOLOGY-PROGRESS SERIES
ISSN journal
01718630 → ACNP
Volume
192
Year of publication
2000
Pages
305 - 313
Database
ISI
SICI code
0171-8630(2000)192:<305:TPSTFR>2.0.ZU;2-1
Abstract
Referees are the backbone of quality control. They need more recognition fo r their work. In an open exchange of opinions among a number of leading edi tors and experienced reviewers one suggestion has wide support: It should n o longer be 'free' to submit a manuscript to a scientific journal. While ca sh payment for reviews is not considered a good idea, a 'payback in kind' s ystem is favored: i.e., if you want to submit papers to a journal you must be willing to review for that journal.