Cn. Bernstein et al., Direct hospital costs for patients with inflammatory bowel disease in a Canadian tertiary care university hospital, AM J GASTRO, 95(3), 2000, pp. 677-683
OBJECTIVE: We set out to determine the direct costs of hospitalizations of
patients with Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis admitted to a universi
ty-affiliate tertiary care hospital and to contrast the costs of medical ve
rsus surgical inpatient care, Crohn's disease versus ulcerative colitis, an
d to identify dominant components of inpatient costs.
METHODS: We used a patient-specific case costing system at Saint Boniface G
eneral Hospital, Winnipeg, Manitoba, for fiscal years 1994 and 1995. We ext
racted all inpatients whose hospital discharge abstracts included ICD-9-CM
codes 555 (Crohn's disease) and 556 (ulcerative colitis) among the top eigh
t discharge diagnoses, and performed a chart review on all cases to ensure
that the hospitalization was for inflammatory bowel disease and the diagnos
es were accurate. We analyzed cases based on their disease diagnosis, prima
ry mode of therapy associated with the hospitalization (medical vs surgical
), and their major diagnosis-related group (DRG). This study evaluated dire
ct patient care costs only and costs are expressed in Canadian dollars.
RESULTS: Of 362 hospital admissions, 325 were eligible and of these admissi
ons 275 belonged to the digestive system DRGs. Seventy-one (37%) were admit
ted more than once during the 2 yr of the study, accounting for 202 (62%) o
f the total number of admissions. The mean cost per admission of all cases
of Crohn's disease was $3,149 (95% confidence interval [CI], $2,665-$3,634)
and for ulcerative colitis was $3,726 (95% CI $3,008-$4,445). Surgical the
rapy cases accounted for 49.8% of all admissions, 57.8% of all hospital day
s, and 60.5% of all costs. Patients treated surgically had more costly hosp
italizations than those treated medically, particularly when analyzing only
nontotal parenteral nutrition (TPN) cases. Surgical treatment admissions w
ere significantly more costly for ulcerative colitis digestive DRG admissio
ns than Crohn's disease. The nondigestive DRG admissions were more costly t
han the digestive DRGs in all categories although this was only statistical
ly different among medically treated Crohn's disease. Patients treated medi
cally were similarly costly whether they had Crohn's disease or ulcerative
colitis. There was no significant difference in cost per admission among ca
ses admitted multiple times, compared with those admitted only once. TPN ca
ses accounted for 9.5% of cases but 27.1% of costs. TPN-associated hospital
izations were more costly than non-TPN-use hospitalizations but these costs
were primarily driven by duration of stay rather than TPN use itself. For
all cases, the top five cost categories in descending order were nursing un
it bed-days, drugs and pharmacy, diagnostic lab tests, operating room, and
diagnostic imaging and endoscopy.
CONCLUSIONS: Using our system we could determine direct costs for inpatient
s with inflammatory bowel disease and the factors that determined increased
costs. Medical therapy admissions were similarly costly between Crohn's di
sease and ulcerative colitis; however, surgical therapy admissions were cos
tlier among ulcerative colitis patients. Admissions for nondigestive DRGs w
ere more costly than those for digestive DRGs. TPN use identified a sicker
group of patients who remained in the hospital longer than nonusers and, no
t surprisingly, these were the costliest patients. (Am J Gastroenterol 2000
;95:677-683. (C) 2000 by Am. Coll. of Gastroenterology).