From the late 19th century Tamil nationalists as represented by the Self-Re
spect Movement, promoted Shaiva Siddhanta as the 'original' Tamil religion
in an imagined ancient past, where social equality and harmony reigned befo
re Brahmans forced the caste system and other social ills on the Tamils, Cl
aims that Shaiva Siddhanta is specifically Tamil and non-Brahman in origin
or essence continue to inform debates concerning Dravidian identity, the ri
ghts of Brahman temple priests, and the language of Hindu worship. These ar
guments have also prompted scholarly inquiry into the history of Tamil Shai
vism. Research shows that Shaiva Siddhanta first developed in central India
among male Brahman spiritual lineages; a distinct regional variation devel
oped later in the south, with non-Brahman Velala leaders and authoritative
writings in Tamil. However; traditional narrartives of the lives of early n
on-Brahman gurus highlight the difficulty of transferring authority from Br
ahmans to Velalas, who are classified as Shudras. This inquiry into Shaiva
Siddhanta's origins both emphasises a long history of ambivalence and accom
modation between two powerful but ritually unequal groups and challenges co
ntinuing efforts to remake this tradition in the service of Tamil identity
politics.