Numerous structure-activity studies combining synthesis and bioassay have b
een performed for the anti-cancer drug Taxol. The four-membered D-ring, an
oxetane, is one of four structural features regarded to be essential for bi
ological activity. This proposition is examined by application of a Taxol-e
pothilone minireceptor, K-i estimation for microtubule binding and docking
of Taxol analogues into a model of the Taxol-tubulin complex. In this way,
we evaluate the two characteristics considered responsible for oxetane func
tion: (1) rigidification of the tetracyclic Taxol core to provide an approp
riate framework for presenting the C-2, C-4, C-13 side chains to the microt
ubule protein and (2) service as a hydrogen-bond acceptor. An energy decomp
osition analysis for a series of Taxol analogues demonstrates that the oxet
ane ring clearly operates by both mechanisms. However, a broader analysis o
f four-membered ring containing compounds, C- and D-seco derivatives, and s
tructures with no oxetane equivalent underscores that the four-membered rin
g is not necessary for Taxol analogue bioactivity. Other functional groups
and ligand-protein binding characteristics are fully capable or delivering
Taxol biobehavior as effectively as the oxetane D-ring. This insight may co
ntribute to the design and development of novel anticancer drugs.