Background. Each year in the United States, the success of 10 million surgi
cally restored carious lesions depends on a favorable tertiary dentin repai
r response to preparation, restoration and patient factor variables. The au
thors investigated the relationship between these variables and dentinal re
sponse,
Methods. Standardized rectangular Class V restoration preparations were cut
into the buccal dentin of intact first or second premolars of 27 patients
without exposing the pulp and were restored. The patients were between 9 an
d 17 years of age. The treated teeth were scheduled for extraction for orth
odontic reasons. After tooth extraction, the tertiary dentin was analyzed h
istomorphometrically.
Results. The area of tertiary reactionary dentin was found to be correlated
using Linear regression analysis of variance with restoration residual den
tin thickness (P = .0024), age of the patient (P = .0045), restoration floo
r surface area (P = .0266) and restoration width (P = .0415). The authors d
id not find a correlation with the premolar position (P = .0594), sex of th
e patient (P = .650), pulpal inflammatory reaction (P = .613) or the time e
lapsed since surgery (P = .531). Restoration with zinc oxide eugenol was fo
und to negatively influence tertiary dentin matrix secretion (post hoc anal
ysis of variance, P = .030).
Conclusions. The age of a patient at treatment, the choice of restorative m
aterial and the size of the restoration preparation are all factors that ca
n positively or negatively affect the pulpal repair response.
Clinical Implications. Age of the patient affects dentin repair capacity an
d may be a factor in treatment planning decisions. Minimizing the cutting o
f dentin, especially the width and base of the preparation, reduces the pro
bability of recurrent pulpal complications.