Mr. Tramer et al., Quantitative estimation of rare adverse events which follow a biological progression: a new model applied to chronic NSAID use, PAIN, 85(1-2), 2000, pp. 169-182
Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) alone are unlikely to provide reliable
estimates of the incidence of rare events because of their limited size. Co
hort, case control, and other observational studies have large numbers but
are vulnerable to various kinds of bias. Wanting to estimate the risk of de
ath from bleeding or perforated gastroduodenal ulcers with chronic usage of
non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) with greater precision, we
developed a model to quantify the frequency of rare adverse events which fo
llow a biological progression. The model combined data from both RCTs and o
bservational studies. We searched systematically for any report of chronic
(greater than or equal to 2 months) use of NSAIDs which gave information on
gastroduodenal ulcer, bleed or perforation, death due to these complicatio
ns, or progression from one level of harm to the next. Fifteen RCTs (19 364
patients exposed to NSAIDs for 2-60 months), three cohort studies (215 076
patients redeeming a NSAID prescription over a 3-12 month period), six cas
e-control studies (2957 cases) and 20 case series (7406), and case reports
(4447) were analysed. In RCTs the incidence of bleeding or perforation in 6
822 patients exposed to NSAIDs was 0.69%; two deaths occurred. Of 11 040 pa
tients with bleeding or perforation with or without NSAID exposure across a
ll reports, 6-16% (average 12%) died; the risk was lowest in RCTs and highe
st in case reports. Death from bleeding or perforation in all controls not
exposed to NSAIDs occurred in 18 out of 849 489 (0.002%). From these number
s we calculated the number-needed-to-treat for one patient to die due to ga
stroduodenal complications with chronic (greater than or equal to 2 months)
NSAIDs as 1/((0.69 x {6-16%, average 12%}) - 0.002%)) = 909-2500 (average
1220). On average 1 in 1200 patients taking NSAIDs for at least 2 months wi
ll die from gastroduodenal complications who would not have died had they n
ot taken NSAIDs. This extrapolates to about 2000 deaths each year in the UK
. (C) 2000 International Association for the Study of Pain. Published by El
sevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.