An. Kingsnorth et al., Lichtenstein patch or Perfix plug-and-patch in inguinal hernia: A prospective double-blind randomized controlled trial of short-term outcome, SURGERY, 127(3), 2000, pp. 276-283
Background. Open mesh used in anterior inguinal hernia repair can be config
ured as a flat patch (Lichtenstein operation) or as a cone-shaped preformed
plug and supplementary patch (plug-and-patch operation; Perfix Plug; Davol
Inc, Cranston, RI).
Methods. One hundred forty-one patients were randomly allocated and blinded
to receive either a Lichtenstein patch or a Perfix plug-and-patch. Informa
tion before the operation and on postoperative pain, analgesic medication,
return to activity and work, and quality of life assessment.
Results. Operating time (32 vs 37.6 minutes) was significantly shorter in t
he plug-and-patch group (P = .01). During days 1 through 8, patients who ha
d undergone the plug-and-patch operation experienced less pain, and their p
hysical functioning on day 3 was significantly better (P = .013). Days of a
nalgesic medication (4.0 vs 4.6 days), return to normal activity (2.8 vs 3.
6 days), return to work (17.0 vs 20.8 days), and total days of work missed
(14.3 vs 16.1 days) were similar in both groups (P = NS for all comparisons
).
Conclusions. Compared with patients who received the Lichtenstein patch for
ambulatory inguinal hernia repair, patients who underwent the Perfix plug-
and-patch operation experienced less postoperative pain in the first 8 days
after the operation but consumed similar postoperative analgesic medicatio
n. The rate of return to normal activity and work is similar in both groups
, which indicates no superiority for the plug-and-patch operation in overal
l rehabilitation and societal costs. Overall hospital costs are greater for
the plug-and-patch operation ($120 [US]) compared with the Lichtenstein pa
tch ($20 [US]), with a negligible (5.6 minutes) saving of operating room ti
me for the plug-and-patch operation.