Study objectives: Airway management in the context of penetrating neck inju
ry is a challenging scenario. Management decisionmaking has not been well s
tudied and the initial airway approach remains controversial. We examined v
arious initial emergency airway techniques and their success in the setting
of penetrating neck trauma.
Methods: A retrospective study was conducted of emergency department intuba
tions in penetrating neck injury from January 1, 1993, to December 31, 1996
, at a Level I trauma center. Cases of out-of-hospital traumatic arrest or
out-of-hospital intubation were excluded. Successful airway management was
defined as endotracheal tube placement confirmed by clinical evaluation, pu
lse oximetry, chest radiography, and end-tidal CO2 detection.
Results: During the study period, 748 consecutive patients with penetrating
neck injury were evaluated in the ED. Of these, 82 (11%) were deemed to re
quire immediate airway management. Twenty-four of the 82 were excluded beca
use of out-of-hospital traumatic arrest or out-of-hospital intubation, resu
lting in a study population of 58 patients. Of these 58 patients, 39 had in
itial rapid sequence intubation using succinylcholine with a 100% success r
ate. Five comatose patients had successful orotracheal intubation without p
aralysis, and 2 patients underwent successful emergency tracheostomy The re
maining 12 patients had initial fiberoptic intubation by otolaryngology cli
nicians, which was unsuccessful in 3 patients. All 3 of these patients were
subsequently successfully orotracheally intubated using the rapid sequence
intubation technique. Therefore, oral endotracheal intubation was the defi
nitive method of airway management in 47 (81%) of the 58 patients and was s
uccessful in all cases.
Conclusion: Rapid sequence intubation was the most commonly performed initi
al technique by emergency physicians and was safe and effective in all case
s attempted. Furthermore, rapid sequence intubation methodology resulted in
successful intubation of the fiberoptic intubation failures. Physicians wi
th airway expertise should consider using rapid sequence intubation as an i
nitial airway technique in managing patients with penetrating neck injury w
ho require airway control.