Kl. Bailey et al., Managing crop losses from foliar diseases with fungicides, rotation, and tillage in the Saskatchewan Parkland, CAN J PLANT, 80(1), 2000, pp. 169-175
The effects of three tillage systems, three crop rotations, and fungicide a
pplications were evaluated on diseases of barley, wheat, canola and pea at
Melfort, SK, from 1994 to 1998. During these years, reduced tillage did not
increase crop losses due to diseases. Four-year rotations with higher prop
ortions of broad-leaved crops and more crop diversity (i.e., canola, pea, f
lax, and barley) had higher yields than rotations with fewer broad-leaved c
rops and less crop diversity (i.e., canola, wheat, barley, and barley). How
ever, these rotations did not influence the severity of septoria leaf blotc
h of wheat, net blotch of barley, the incidence of sclerotinia stem rot and
blackleg of canola, or the severity of mycosphaerella blight of pea. Inter
plot interference may have been a factor influencing some diseases in plots
, as the size was only 270 m(2). Fungicide application of propiconazole on
Harrington barley decreased foliar disease severity and increased yield by
23%, seed weight by 13%, and kernel plumpness by 25%. Application of azoxys
trobin decreased foliar disease and increased pea yield 29% and seed weight
by 7% for the pea cultivars Express and Highlight. Foliar disease severity
on AC Taber wheat was reduced by application of propiconazole in 2 of 4 yr
, but the yield response was very inconsistent. Similarly, AC Excel canola
had inconsistent disease and yield response to applications of propiconazol
e and benomyl, but levels of sclerotinia stem rot and blackleg were very lo
w in all years. These results indicate that reduced tillage will not result
in significantly higher levels of disease that require fungicide inputs to
maintain yield. Moving from cereal-based rotations to more diverse, broad-
leaved based rotations improves the yield of cereals. However, regardless o
f tillage or rotation, higher yields may be obtained in barley and pea with
fungicides for control of leaf spot disease in susceptible cultivars.