The paper presents a general equilibrium model of a pure exchange economy w
ith stochastic endowments, in which speculation in the forward market is pr
ofitable and stabilizes prices but is useless from a welfare point of view.
Reconciling the Siegel paradox with the theory of incomplete markets, we s
how that banning speculation by closing the forward market may increase soc
ial welfare. We also show that the addition of a market might reduce the ga
ins from international trade for all participating countries. JEL Classific
ation Numbers: F10, F11, F19.