A prospective evaluation of 331 university women who were initiating use of
oral contraceptive pills (OCPs), a cervical cap, diaphragm-spermicide, or
other spermicidal methods was done to assess the effects of commonly used c
ontraceptive methods on the vaginal flora. Vaginal introital cultures were
performed at baseline and then weekly for 1 month. The prevalence of Escher
ichia coli vaginal colonization and of abnormal vaginal Gram stain scores (
Nugent criteria) increased significantly among women using a cervical cap o
r diaphragm-spermicide but not among women using OCPs, Women with E. coli c
olonization were significantly more likely to have an abnormal Nugent score
and an absence of lactobacilli, In a multivariate model, use of spermicida
l contraception in the preceding week was associated with an abnormal Nugen
t score and with colonization with E. coli, Enterococcus species, and anaer
obic gram-negative rods. Thus, spermicidal methods of contraception are ass
ociated with alterations of the vaginal microflora that consequently may pr
edispose women to genitourinary infections.