J. Shimada et al., Conformation of amylose in aqueous solution: Small-angle X-ray scattering measurements and simulations, J PHYS CH B, 104(9), 2000, pp. 2136-2147
Small-angle X-ray scattering profiles for an amylose fragment (maltoheptaos
e) in aqueous solution were observed and compared with the theoretical prof
iles calculated for an ensemble of chain conformations generated by molecul
ar dynamics simulations and Monte Carlo simulations. The Monte Carlo result
s based on the disaccharide conformation energy map obtained without explic
itly considering surrounding water molecules were in satisfactory agreement
with the experimental results, provided that the effective dielectric cons
tant was set to four. In contrast, the results of the fully solvated molecu
lar dynamics simulations performed using the Cff91, Cff, Gromos, Glycam93,
and Glycam99 force-fields were unexpectedly different from each other. Amon
g them, Cff91 gave most satisfactory agreement with experiment, but the oth
er fields yielded conformations that were somewhat or highly extended. It w
as also shown that recently developed Glycam99 is a significant improvement
over Glycam 93. The representative snapshots of the two successful simulat
ions resembled the regular helical structure reported by Goldsmith ct al. (
J. Mol. Biol. 1982, 156, 411). The source of the large force-field dependen
ce was investigated by examining the various Ramachandran-like plots for th
e glycosidic torsion angles. For comparison, similar plots of ab initio ene
rgy for maltose (i.e., a fragment with two glucose units) were also calcula
ted at the Hartree-Fock level, although in a simplified manner. These plots
suggest that the extended conformation arises from too strong a preference
for a certain rotational isomeric state of the glycosidic linkage. A proce
dure to remedy this over-preference can be devised, although a need of furt
her elaboration of the force-field is indicated. The significance of force-
fields is also illustrated in modeling a cyclodextrin composed of 14 glucos
e units.