The growth stresses in a-alumina scales growing on stoichiometric NiAl duri
ng oxidation in air at 1100 degrees C have been measured by two X-ray diffr
action techniques. the classic rocking technique and a newly developed fixe
d-incidence multiplane (FIM) technique. The growth stresses were found to b
e within the experimental uncertainty of the measurements, ie., near zero.
Measurement of the residual stresses using an optical-fluorescence spectros
copy (OFS) technique in adherent regions of the scale, after cooling to roo
m temperature, were consistent with the growth stresses having been negligi
bly small. These measurements contrast with previous measurements of growth
stresses in alpha-alumina growing on Fe-Cr-Al alloys, using the FIM techni
que, which indicated compressive growth stresses on the order of 1 GPa. Pos
sible reasons for these differences are discussed.