Ma. Ramos et al., Acoustic properties of amorphous metals at very low temperatures: Applicability of the tunneling model, PHYS REV B, 61(2), 2000, pp. 1059-1067
Studies of the relative change of sound velocity Delta upsilon/upsilon and
internal friction Q(-1) of a metallic glass (PdSiCu) in the temperature ran
ge 0.2 mK less than or equal to T < 0.5 R and at kHz frequencies reveal sig
nificant deviations from the predictions of the tunneling model for both ac
oustic properties. At the lowest temperatures, the logarithmic temperature
dependence of Delta upsilon/upsilon is no longer observed, and in addition,
the sound-velocity variation strongly depends on the applied acoustic inte
nsity. In clear contrast to the predicted "plateau" in the internal frictio
n, we observe Q(-1) proportional to ln T throughout the whole temperature r
ange investigated, the magnitude of Q(-1) being dependent on the applied st
rain, too. The apparent discrepancy between experimental data and tunneling
model is traced back to different considerations of strain-dependent effec
ts: in contrast to the experiment, the tunneling model is linear in strain
and thus does not account for any strain dependence. As a consequence, comp
arison between experimental results and tunneling model should be possible
for zero-strain values of Delta upsilon/upsilon and Q(-1) which have been d
etermined by detailed investigations of the acoustic intensity dependence o
f both acoustic properties at different constant temperatures. The main res
ult of this work is that the tunneling-model behavior is unveiled only in t
he limit of zero strain. Thus, for the first time the behavior expected wit
hin the tunneling model for an amorphous metal has been scrutinized: we rep
ort a logarithmic temperature dependence for Delta upsilon/upsilon at T>0.2
mK and a temperature-independent plateau of Q(-1) at T>0.5 mK.